NETSoon

Docs Fault Lab

Last look

A proposer delays its commitment to see the others first. Its block is dropped and the disagreeing attestations skip the cblock.

A proposer waits to see what its co-proposers put in their blocks before fixing its own: the last look a single leader has today. Shows Lemma 2.3, proposal hiding.

The attack in the run

In window 4, proposer 3 sends its commitment 28 ms after it would have, past the 2δlocal = 20 ms exchange window. Everything else it does is correct.

What the protocol does

Its co-proposers close their exchange 20 ms after it starts (The 2δlocal window). Proposer 3's commitment has not arrived, so both attest it as late, ⊥, and release their keys. Their blocks were sealed before proposer 3's commitment, and the late block can only be dropped: whatever proposer 3 learned by waiting cannot reach the cblock alongside the blocks it looked at.

Proposer 3's own attestation names all three commitments, so the attestation vectors disagree. No set is agreed (Agreement, condition (a)), validators vote skip, and the cblock is skip-certified.

The evidence

The run ends done with late_block_dropped for the late proposer and slot, then skip_certificate for the cblock. The evidence of a recorded run:

outcome.json evidence
[
  {
    "description": "Proposer 3 committed 28 ms late; its co-proposers attested it as late (deadline 20000 us after start), so its block can only be dropped.",
    "hashes": [],
    "kind": "late_block_dropped",
    "observedFragments": null,
    "proposer": 3,
    "signatures": [],
    "slot": 64,
    "threshold": null,
    "txId": null
  },
  {
    "description": "The late proposer's own attestation disagrees with its co-proposers' vectors, so no set is agreed and the cblock is skip-certified.",
    "hashes": [],
    "kind": "skip_certificate",
    "observedFragments": null,
    "proposer": null,
    "signatures": [],
    "slot": 64,
    "threshold": null,
    "txId": null
  }
]

Run it

Terminal
acrux lab run --scenario last-look --seed demo --out runs/last-look

Or start it on /lab, or with POST /v1/lab/runs and { "scenario": "last-look" }. Fault Lab runs