NETSoon

Docs Fault Lab

Equivocation

A proposer signs two different commitments for one slot. The two signatures are a slashing proof and the cblock is skipped.

A proposer shows different blocks to different co-proposers, to split the validators. Shows Lemma 2.4, accountable equivocation.

The attack in the run

On slot 64, the first of window 4, proposer 3 sends its co-proposers a second commitment with a different hash, signed with the same key as the first.

What the protocol does

Two commitments for one slot, both under proposer 3's signature, are a proof of equivocation: anyone can check both signatures against the proposer's identity, and a correct proposer never signs two. A validator that has seen it cannot consider the slot agreed (Agreement, condition (d)), so it votes skip and the cblock is skip-certified.

The proof names proposer 3 and no one else, and it holds the two signed messages a slashing rule needs.

The evidence

The run ends done with slashing_proof with the two commitment hashes and the two signatures, then skip_certificate for the cblock. The evidence of a recorded run:

outcome.json evidence
[
  {
    "description": "Two commitments for one slot, both signed by the same proposer: a slashing proof. Agreement fails and the cblock is skipped.",
    "hashes": [
      "2a34e6e9373b4998b6009951cf45bbd519425463b0e3f9bd5d278094c80a9a02",
      "d534e6e9373b4998b6009951cf45bbd519425463b0e3f9bd5d278094c80a9a02"
    ],
    "kind": "slashing_proof",
    "observedFragments": null,
    "proposer": 3,
    "signatures": [
      "3Sdviey443aJBnCoC2dgNLXwxvTETHstdN1YxNXaKCaMcSHJigZQ8jxXtcvt6nowqTpx4YDJ2KThgWzNgtUL5WXv",
      "2YkDQhvGBf2ha72NLBtXjyJNcZaDtMPnLeGgUzcqTAHiv3BMCRbBHkomS4bGuehYZF6a7QGz8zzt2B7D4mEiD85M"
    ],
    "slot": 64,
    "threshold": null,
    "txId": null
  },
  {
    "description": "Validators that saw the slashing proof cannot agree on the slot (Agreed (d)), and the cblock is skip-certified.",
    "hashes": [],
    "kind": "skip_certificate",
    "observedFragments": null,
    "proposer": null,
    "signatures": [],
    "slot": 64,
    "threshold": null,
    "txId": null
  }
]

Run it

Terminal
acrux lab run --scenario equivocation --seed demo --out runs/equivocation

Or start it on /lab, or with POST /v1/lab/runs and { "scenario": "equivocation" }. Fault Lab runs